Middlesex
gave us a lot to talk and think about. Most of us loved the depth of history from
Greco-Turkish War to the rise of The Church of Islam and the Detroit riots, the
narrative going back and forth but never losing its thread. As Cathy pointed
out the ongoing story of the silkworm weaving throughout the story also kept it
all together and moving at the same time. Annette found the historical context
a bit much and was keener to find out how Calliope was coping with the changes
to her body and life. Phil loved the way Eugenides successfully wrote in the first-person
and then in the third and again didn’t lose track of where he was going. There
were poignant moments like the teenager Calliope’s horror at seeing her
identified as a ’monster’ in a library reference book.
And I’ve
got to mention of Cheryl’s eureka moment when she realized the title of the
book had something to do with Cal’s confused gender. Good work Cheryl!
So the
scores are:
Alison
8
Anna
9.5
Annette
8
Cathy
8
Cheryl
9
Genevieve
10
Kristy
9
Megan
10
Phil
10
Average 9.05
Couldn't make the meeting but I loved the book. 10 for me. Original story. Didn't know how it would end.
ReplyDelete